5 X-Men It Would Really Suck To Be


Like this graffiti, but crappier. (Photo credit: Watzek Library Digital Projects)

I grew up a huge X-Men fan.

I read the comics when I could get my paws on them, I watched the cartoon series with a religious fervor that would make any zealot jealous, and when they started making movies, I went to midnight showings with my friends and spent our lunch hours eating full-pound burgers and shoestring fries from Napp’s Grill in Hamilton, Montana and re-watching old episodes.

Yeah, I was a fan.

There are some seriously cool mutations. Kitty Pryde can walk through walls. Wolverine can heal from just about anything. Storm controls the weather, and Colossus is a one-man tank of a dude. And that’s not even mentioning Jean Grey, Cyclops, Professor X, and Magneto.

And yet.

There is a darker side to the X-Men. A crappier side. A “why-oh-why-did-I-get-THIS-mutation” side.

Even as a kid, I looked at some of the X-Men and thought, “Wow, that would really, really suck. Genetics, you’re a meanie-pants.”

Some are lethal. Some are rather boring. Others simply very inconvenient.

I thought it was time to share some of these craptastic mutations with the world.

Rogue in Wolverine and the X-Men

Rogue in Wolverine and the X-Men (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

1. Rogue

So, you can borrow anyone’s powers! Any time! Cool, right? NO. It’s total bullshit. Because the little fine print at the bottom of her DNA says in a breezy, nonchalant sort of voice that poor Marie can’t touch anyone EVAR.

If she touches a mutant, she siphons off their powers. If she touches a human, they freaking die. Or end up comatose, whatevs.

So that long flirtation match she has with sexy Cajun Gambit? Unconsummated.  Though she does sort of swipe Gambit’s powers for a time when they’re on the outs and manages to bunk up with Iceman (can’t say I blame her). But that ends when her old powers return, and she’s once again doomed to a life of celibacy and hasty, very dangerous kisses.

Though she gets some control later on, that’s like saying, “Okay, so you’ll be like a walking, unstoppable machine gun around people for a decade or two. Then it’ll be like, okay.”

No, thank you.


“Aw, man, my iPhone’s busted. Call Jimmy over there in that field.” Siryn (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

2. Siryn

She yells.

Really, really loud.

Useful if you want to, say, shatter everyone’s eardrums within a mile radius or really piss off some fishermen, but otherwise a bummer.

Sure, she can use her sonic vibrat-O-waves to fly through the air, but she has to scream at top voice to do it. And that doesn’t change the fact that her superpower is yelling. Really, really loud yelling.

Talk about a shrill neighbour.

Mystique (comics)

Mystique (comics) (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

3. Mystique

I’m not going to argue that she doesn’t come into her own later on. But early life as Mystique?

She’s blue.

Anyone who’s ever been bullied in school can tell you how not blue you need to be to escape the worst of child cruelty.

Even though she can shift into just about any humanoid shape as she hones her powers, for most of Mystique’s early life she can be everyone but herself. Talk about childhood trauma. She can’t even show her real face for fear of being shot, stoned, or humiliated.


“Hey, I went to Weapon X, and all I got was super-cancer and dissociative identity disorder! Thanks, Stryker!” Deadpool (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

4. Deadpool

This guy started out with a mutation similar to Wolverine’s, in that he could heal super quickly.

And then William Stryker came along and made everything absolutely and completely miserable.

Deadpool is basically a botched science experiment. Thanks to Stryker, he has a conglomerate of random superpowers like superstrength and speed and a near invulnerability to psychic attacks.

But he is nuts.

Not only did Stryker’s poking and prodding result in Deadpool’s cancer going supercharged and disfiguring his entire body, but it seems to have left him with psychosis and dissociative identity disorder. Which is to say, you never know who the fuck you’re talking to.

“Deadpool isn’t here today! This is Bonko, the Sadistic Clown! HAR-HAR-HAR!”

(He never said that.)

And this guy doesn’t die. He’s stuck with his insanity and superpowers for over 800 years.

I think I’ll pass and just have the chicken.

Cyclops (comics)

“But…I just opened my eyes! NOW EVERYBODY’S DEAD!” Cyclops (comics) (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

5. Cyclops

Imagine little Scott Summers hitting puberty. He’s all bundled up in snowy Anchorage, Alaska. There’s a pretty girl he wants to ask out. He clears his throat, hoping it won’t crack.

Then he opens his eyes and incinerates her on the spot.

Is that love in the air, or simply burning flesh?

None of that happened. But Scott Summers almost had it worse. He was on a plane with his dad when they got attacked by a spaceship. So what does daddy do? Throw Scotty in a parachute with his brother and chuck them out of a crashing plane.

Scott bashes his head on a rock and ends up with little to no control over the optic blasts that can level buildings, let alone little pubescent girlies.

He has to wear his protective glasses at all times, otherwise he’ll accidentally murder someone just by looking at them. If looks could kill, right?

Cyclops, indeed.

There are plenty of superpowers the mutants in X-Men have that I am rather envious of. Like Nightcrawler’s teleportation (incidentally, this also comes with a side of blue), or Jean Grey’s many abilities. Then there are the rather stupid ones like Jubilee’s fireworks, which are more like an unfortunate party trick than anything very useful.

But the X-Men above? They got the Hannibal Lecter of genomes and mutations that want everyone dead — or just really irritated.

What X-Men would you hate to be? What superpowers would bum you out if you drew them from the genetic hat?


About Emmie Mears

Saving the world from brooding, one self-actualized vampire at a time.

Posted on August 16, 2012, in Superheroes, urban fantasy and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 16 Comments.

  1. I’ve only watched the movies, and never read the comics. I always felt sorry for Rogue and Cyclops, that would be a horrible way to live, knowing that at anytime you could accidentally kill someone with just a touch or a look. It would be amazing to be Nightcrawler though! I mean just thinking I want to be in Paris or London and you’re there! Awesome! Even if you were blue!

  2. Jean Grey. Imagine what it would be like to be a telepath AND an overthinker/worrier? Or to go through the whole rebirth and turn evil cycle because of the Pheonix, and kill your husband in every single revamped Pheonix storyline. (That would be horrible.) Let’s face it. It sucks to be Jean Grey. She’s nothing but a plot device.

    • Yeah, she has it rough. That is for damn sure.

      I dunno about her being a total plot device though. In X-Men Forever she has some pretty cool character development that doesn’t revolve around her becoming Phoenix or murdering lovers. That’s a kind of cool series — I actually used panels from it at my wedding because it involved her relationship with Logan. (We had Wolverine and Jean Grey cake toppers. 🙂 )

  3. Despite his various, insane, and hilarious attempts to be a part of the X-Men, Cyclops (that square) never let Deadpool be part of the team. However, his psychosis and dissociative identity disorder, along with an unnatural attraction to Bea Arthur, make Deadpool my favorite superhero/antihero ever. The Cable and Deadpool series was hilariously epic and awesome. Speaking of Cable, now that is an X-Men it would suck to be. Hugely powerful, but a terrible messianic complex and a techno-organic virus constantly trying to kill you.

    • Clay Schroeder, I am so glad you exist.

      Yeah, Deadpool is definitely awesome — I just wouldn’t want to walk half a foot in his shoes. 🙂

      I will have to read the Cable/Deadpool series you mention. I need more X-Men in my life. I need to nurse my childhood crushes on Iceman and Gambit somehow (Rogue’s lucky in love, if not in DNA).

      And yeah, Cyclops is pretty much the biggest square in square-onia. Yet one more reason it would suck to be Scott Summers — he has no idea how to have fun.

  4. Hi, Emmie! I enjoyed this article very much. One of the best ‘writing superpowers’ you have is the hability to shift from a more peacefull, relaxed, and highly rich in vocabulary and grammar way of writing to a terse, dry, kick-in-the-brains style. And you do konw how to play with words and have fun with it, like “is that love in the air, or simply burning flesh?” I think it’s clear you really enjoy writing, and that makes a huge difference…. Keep on, gives more good stuff!

  5. Eleni Sakellis

    Thanks Emmie, great article here. I love X-Men, too. Rogue’s deal is pretty harsh, and Cyclops’ too. And I agree about Nightcrawler’s teleportation, that’s a cool power to have. Think of all the time and money he saves:)

  6. Kourtney Heintz

    I loved the X-Men comics too. I always thought it would stink to be The Beast. Rogue’s powers were probably the most miserable. 🙂

  7. Easy – Dazzler. Imagine being stuck in disco forever…. I’d rather be toad.

  8. Personally, I think it would really suck to be Quicksilver. I mean, if you’ve read the one X-factor where’ he’s underoging a session with Doc Samson, and it’s revealed that to him, it seems as if the rest of the world is moving at a snail’s pace, like being stuck in traffic, or being in line at a fast food joint and the guy in front can’t figure aout what he wants. For him it’s like that all the FREAKING time. No wonder he’s so surly and short tempered.
    BTW, non of the X-men have anything on the Inhuman King Black Bolt. I mean to be able to fly and be super strong but unable to talk without causing a big disaster? Heck in Marval a lot of the time having superpowers sucks.

  1. Pingback: Tracey’s Seal of Approval: Facebook Faux-pas, X-Men & 80s Nostalgia – Mimosas @ Midnight

  2. Pingback: Mutant Powers and Week 8 The Next Big Thing | Debra Kristi's Blog

%d bloggers like this: